How does it affect his impression of his brother? What is your opinion of Mike's wife, Abby? As a non-Catholic what does she think of the McGanns, of their religious faith, and of Art?ġ4. Talk about Mike's relationship with Kath. Why did Aidan affect Art so deeply? What about Kath? What were her feelings toward Art?ġ3. Talk about Art's relationship with Aidan Conlon and his mother, Kath. 'Strength Amid Difficulties.' Does this describe Art? What about Sheila and Mike? Would you consider those three words to be a good definition of faith?ġ2. Shelia recalls that at the entrance of each building at the seminary where Art studied for the priesthood was carved the motto: Vigor in Arduis. In sharing her brother's past, Sheila reflects, 'Art's story is, to me, the story of my family, with all its darts and dodges and mysterious omissions.' What do the events of Art's life reveal about the McGanns? What do they reveal about our own lives and modern society? What about the Catholic Church?ġ1.

How does this reflect his own life? How does it reflect hers?ġ0. You give up your place in the world.' Explain the meaning of Art's words to Sheila. Take them away, and you lose any hope for connection. 'Love to marriage to home and family: connect those dots, and you get the approximate shape of most people's lives.

Was he a good shepherd? Was he a good man? Did Art fail his faith or did faith fail him?ĩ. How would you describe Art? What did you think of him? Why did he become a priest? 8. But can doubt strengthen our beliefs, our 'faith'?ħ. Do you think that view still holds? How have societal views of priests-and other religious leaders-been affected by the abuse scandals? What role does the media play in shaping our views? What do the news stories leave out?Ħ. Shelia remembers that as a child she saw her priest as 'other than human, made of different stuff than the rest of us.' Explain what she means. How do these siblings compare to each other? What defines their reaction to the scandal and to Art? What were their roles in Art's story, and how did each of their outlooks and actions affect the other? How are each of the family members ultimately transformed by events?ĥ.

Describe the relationships between Sheila and her brothers. How do you define faith? What does faith mean to each of the characters, especially the siblings, Art, Sheila, and Mike ? Is this a good title for the novel?Ĥ. What role does religion play in each of the family members' lives? How do their religious beliefs-or lack of them-define who they are? Is religion a solace for the family or a burden? Are there sins or transgressions that are unforgivable?ģ. How do these quotes reflect the novel's themes?Ģ. For the epigraph, Jennifer Haigh uses two quotes, one involving sin, the other about living by the Rule.

Faith haigh